Gold and Emerging Markets

Understanding Emerging Market Returns: Equity vs. Gold

In the 21st century, the performance of equity markets and gold has shown some interesting trends, especially in emerging markets. By comparing the returns in local currencies, we can see how different markets have performed in both these asset classes. While many countries have seen gold outperform equities, India stands out as an exception.

Gold’s Strong Returns in Emerging Markets

When looking at several emerging markets, gold has delivered better returns than equity markets in most of them. For example, in Turkey, gold has outperformed the equity markets by 8% over the last 23 years. Similarly, Argentina has seen a 6% excess return from gold, while Brazil’s figure stands at 5.7%. This pattern continues across countries like Poland, Chile, and South Korea, where gold consistently outshines equities.

These strong returns suggest that gold has been a reliable asset in these economies, especially as a hedge against market fluctuations. Many of these countries have experienced volatility in their local currencies, which has made gold an attractive and stable investment option.

India: The Exception to the Trend

India, however, tells a different story. Over the last two decades, equity markets in India have outperformed gold. Indian equities have delivered returns of 13.8%, compared to 12.3% from gold. This makes India one of the few emerging markets where gold has not outpaced the stock market.

One reason for this is India’s relatively stable currency in recent years. The stability in the Indian rupee has meant that the equity markets have been able to deliver strong returns, without the kind of currency devaluation seen in other countries. As a result, gold has not been able to surpass equity performance in India, unlike in other emerging markets.

The Role of Currency Stability

Currency stability plays a crucial role in these trends. In countries like Turkey, Argentina, and Brazil, local currencies have struggled against the US dollar, which has helped gold shine as a stronger investment option. Gold tends to perform well when local currencies weaken, offering investors a safe haven against inflation and economic instability.

India’s more stable currency, particularly over the last decade, has allowed its equity markets to thrive. This stability has created an anomaly, where Indian equities have remained competitive with gold. However, if the rupee had faced the same challenges as other emerging market currencies, India’s returns might have mirrored those of its peers.

The Long-Term Value of Gold

The data from these emerging markets suggests that gold remains a strong performer, especially as a hedge against local market risks. While equities can offer higher returns during stable times, gold’s value lies in its ability to protect wealth during economic downturns or periods of currency weakness. It is clear from this comparison that ignoring gold as part of a diversified portfolio could mean missing out on important protection and returns.

For those in emerging markets, having some exposure to gold can be a smart move. While equities can provide growth, gold offers a hedge that can keep a portfolio balanced and secure, especially during times of market or currency stress.

Watch the Video Here