Index investing has gained significant popularity in recent years as a passive investment strategy. The idea is simple: instead of trying to beat the market by investing in individual stocks, you invest in an index fund that tracks the performance of a specific market index. This approach offers diversification and is often touted as a safe and low-cost way to invest. However, it’s essential to understand that index investing is not without its risks.
In this article, we will examine the possibility of index investing failing by looking at two real-life examples: the Hang Seng market and the Japanese market. By analyzing these cases, we can gain valuable insights into the potential pitfalls of relying solely on index investing.
Hang Seng Market: Two Decades of Stagnation
The Hang Seng market in Hong Kong presents an interesting case study. Over the past 23 years, the index has gone nowhere. In fact, it is currently trading below its 2000 high of 18,000, at around 16,200. This means that investors who have held onto their investments in the Hang Seng market over this period have experienced negative returns.
While some argue that the Hang Seng market’s stagnation can be attributed to unique factors such as Chinese control over Hong Kong’s corporates, it does bring to light the important question: can this happen to other markets, like India?
The Japanese Market: A Rollercoaster Ride
Another example worth considering is the Japanese market. From 1983 to 1997, the Japanese index experienced a remarkable five-fold increase, soaring from 8,000 to nearly 40,000. This exponential growth was driven by liquidity pouring into the market. However, after reaching its peak, the Japanese market entered a long period of stagnation.
While it may seem unimaginable, it’s worth contemplating if a similar scenario could unfold in other markets, like India. Could the Nifty index, which currently sits at around 22,000, potentially reach 110,000 by 2030? While such projections seem far-fetched, history has shown us that markets can behave unexpectedly, and strange things can happen.
Liquidity and Market Sentiment
One crucial factor that can significantly impact market performance is liquidity. When a market becomes a magnet for liquidity, regardless of valuation or overheating concerns, funds keep pouring in. This influx of funds leads to a rising tide, lifting all boats, or in this case, shares.
Now, let’s consider the Indian market. If India were to receive substantial inflows of foreign and domestic funds over the next seven years, with limited supply being added to the market, the existing stock prices would inevitably rise due to increased demand. This is similar to what we’ve seen in real estate markets where there are more buyers than available properties, driving prices up.
In such scenarios, whether the rise is rational or justified by valuations becomes less relevant. The key takeaway is that it is possible for an index to rise rapidly within a short period. However, it’s important to note that such a surge may not be sustainable over the long term.
Index Investing: Not a Guaranteed Success
While index investing has enjoyed significant success in the US and India thus far, it is vital to recognize that no investment strategy is guaranteed. Although index investing seems appealing due to its simplicity and low costs, it is not immune to failure.
As we have seen with the Hang Seng market and the Japanese market, index investing can fall short in certain circumstances. External factors such as political instability or economic maturity can significantly impact the performance of an index.
Thus, it’s critical to be aware of the risks associated with index investing and adopt strategies that can potentially outperform or protect against market downturns. Relying solely on index investing exposes investors to the whims of the market, leaving them vulnerable to periods of stagnation or even substantial losses.
To mitigate the risks associated with index investing, it is crucial to go beyond a passive approach and incorporate active strategies like momentum investing into your investment approach. By actively managing your investments or following a strategy that aims to beat the index, you can potentially capitalize on market opportunities and mitigate the impact of market downturns.
If you have any questions, please write to support@weekendinvesting.com
