The Commodities-to-Equity Ratio: A Historical Perspective and Potential Future Implications

The commodities-to-equity ratio measures the relative valuation between commodity prices and equity market performance. By studying the historical trends and potential future implications of this ratio, investors can gain valuable insights into market dynamics.

Historical Trends

Over the past 53 years, the commodities-to-equity ratio has experienced notable fluctuations. The below enclosed chart by Tavi Costa from Crescat Capital reveals that the ratio has moved from around one to approximately nine at several points in history. These spikes in the ratio tend to coincide with specific market conditions and economic trends.

In the 1970s, during the nifty 50 stock bubble, the ratio was low as equities were performing exceptionally well. However, as the price of oil skyrocketed and a period of inflationary pressures emerged, commodities became more valuable, leading to an increase in the ratio.

Following this period, the ratio normalised to around four levels for the next decade or two. However, in 1992, there was another significant spike in the ratio, primarily driven by developments in the Gulf region. This spike coincided with a strong rally in the stock market, especially during the tech bubble until 2000. The ratio then decreased once again to around two levels.

The stock market crash of 2008 and the surge in oil prices to nearly $150 per barrel resulted in another spike in the commodities-to-equity ratio. During this time, commodities, particularly gold, were in high demand, while equities faced significant challenges. The ratio reached its peak of nine during this period.

Since then, the stock market has performed well, while commodities have not maintained the same momentum. This decline in the ratio, currently at approximately 0.6, reflects the outperformance of equities compared to commodities in recent years.

Future Implications

Analysing the historical trends of the commodities-to-equity ratio can provide insights into potential future market conditions. While it is challenging to predict future movements accurately, market participants should remain open to the possibility of future spikes in the ratio.

It is important to note that these spikes tend to occur in approximately ten-year intervals. Therefore, investors, especially younger ones who have primarily experienced a period of stock market growth, should consider the possibility of a future phase where commodities outstrip financial products significantly.

During such a phase, commodities like oil, gold, metals, and agricultural products may experience substantial price increases, potentially resembling a bubble-like evaluation. Equities, on the other hand, may not fare as well during this period. Therefore, diversifying one’s portfolio to include commodities can help investors take advantage of these potential market movements.

Recent market trends already hint at a potential shift towards commodities. The charts of orange juice, cocoa, sugar, iron ore, and gold all indicate either rapid upward movements or the process of making new highs. This suggests that the commodities market may experience significant growth in the near future.

While the exact timing of this shift remains uncertain, it is wise to remain vigilant and stay informed about commodity-related opportunities. It is worth considering investments in sectors associated with commodities, such as oil stocks, steel stocks, and sugar stocks, as they would likely benefit from the anticipated rally.

However, it is important to approach this potential commodity-driven phase with caution. Inflationary concerns and collapsing demand due to rising prices could suppress other segments of the market. Therefore, carefully evaluating the potential risks and rewards of investing in commodities should be a key consideration.

If you have any questions, please write to support@weekendinvesting.com