The Illusion of Market Projection
In this blog, we discuss an interesting chart from BC Alpha Research that sheds light on the projections made by analysts and strategists for the market. This chart encompasses data from the past 23 to 24 years, ranging from 1999 to 2023. Although this data pertains to the US market, it still provides valuable insights that we can apply to other markets
The Consistent Positivity Bias
What is particularly intriguing is that in the last 23 years, there hasn’t been a single projected change for the market that was negative. Every year, without exception, the collective opinion of analysts and strategists has consistently leaned towards a positive market outlook. Regardless of whether the projected growth was modest (such as 4%) or substantial (up to 18%), the consensus has always been positive.
Learning from Historical Patterns
Additionally, it is noteworthy that following a dull or down year, the projections for the subsequent year tend to be higher. On average, the projected annual change falls within the range of about 8% to 9%. Interestingly, market performance does not always align with these projections. For instance, in 2008, the expectation was an 8% increase, but the markets experienced a significant downturn. Similarly, in 2020, there was a projection of a mere 1% increase, but the markets were heavily impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic.
The Fallacy of Projections
These findings challenge the belief that market projections hold substantial value. It becomes evident that there is a strong bias towards positive outcomes, irrespective of actual market conditions. Considering the track record of analysts and strategists, it becomes increasingly clear that their projections often miss the mark.
A Contradictory Projection
An interesting contradiction arises when we examine the data regarding the one year in which the industry projected a down year. In 2023, the calendar year was projected to be a down year. However, the SNP 500 index actually experienced a remarkable increase of almost 18% to 19%. This discrepancy amplifies the fallacy of blindly adhering to market projections. It highlights the futility of relying on analyst recommendations, TV news, and business journal opinions.
The Importance of Individual Strategy
The above evidence urges us to question the necessity of depending on external projections for investment decisions. Instead, developing a sound strategy based on personal research and market analysis becomes essential. By adopting a diligent approach and allowing the strategy to unfold, one can strive to outperform the market.
This data clearly reveals two significant insights. Firstly, people commonly possess a biased perception towards positive market outcomes. This bias shapes their projections, leading to an inherent positivity in their predictions. Secondly, despite this pervasive positivity, analysts and strategists are often proven wrong.
Hence, grasping the illusion of market projections is crucial. Investors should take caution not to blindly follow projections and recommendations from experts without conducting their own due diligence.
If you have any questions, please write to support@weekendinvesting.com
