Is India’s Stock Market Overvalued? Debunking the Bloomberg Report
Recently, there has been a report published by Bloomberg that claims India’s stock market is highly overvalued. According to the report, the stock valuations in India are at a premium compared to their ten-year average. However, upon closer examination, it becomes clear that this analysis fails to consider the inherent nature of bull markets and the fluctuations in stock valuations.
During bull markets, stock valuations tend to surpass their ten-year averages. This is not a surprising or magical phenomenon but rather a natural outcome of market dynamics. The ten-year average includes both periods of market downturns, as well as periods of growth and stagnation. Therefore, beating the ten-year average is actually a positive sign indicating a thriving market.
The Bloomberg report highlights that India’s current stock valuations are at 20.5 times earnings compared to the ten-year average of 18.5 times earnings, representing a roughly 10-11% increase. While the report labels this increase as a cause for concern, it fails to consider the bigger picture and the potential for further growth.
From an optimistic point of view, if we analyse the historical valuations, we observe that in 2020, the valuations reached 24 or even 24.5 times earnings. If the stock market were to reach these levels again, it would represent a significant jump of around 20% from its current position. In other words, if the Nifty index were to rise from 20,200 to 24,000, we would effectively return to the valuation achieved in 2021.
The report’s intention seems to discourage investors from considering India as an investment destination based on the premise that the market is overpriced. However, this overlooks the fact that India has experienced higher valuations in the past, rendering the current valuation of 20.5 times earnings relatively moderate.
Furthermore, it is important to note that predicting earnings and their impact on stock prices is a complex and challenging task. It is often difficult to decipher the intricate dynamics of the earnings game accurately. In such instances, it is wiser to focus on price movement rather than solely relying on earnings data.
Investors should track the momentum of the market and consider the potential for future price appreciation. The possibility of a 20% surge in the stock market, followed by earnings catching up later, is a viable scenario. Therefore, rather than being deterred by the Bloomberg report, investors should adopt a comprehensive approach to analyse the market and evaluate the potential for future growth.
If you have any questions, please write to support@weekendinvesting.com
