The Derivatives Trading Mania in India: A Cause for Concern

One of the trends that has caught my attention is the growing popularity of derivatives trading in India. In recent years, there has been an unprecedented surge in the turnover of futures and options (F&O) contracts, leading to a concerning ratio of derivatives turnover to cash turnover. In this article, we delve into the reasons behind this derivatives trading mania, its potential impact on investors, and the broader implications for the Indian market.

The Alarming Turnover Ratio

To put things into perspective, the derivatives turnover to cash turnover ratio in India currently stands at a staggering 400+. This means that for every Rs1 traded in the cash market, Rs422 gets traded in futures and options. This ratio was a mere 32 times just before the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2019. The exponential rise in derivatives trading is a matter of concern, considering the high proportion of traders who are not making any profits. According to the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), more than 85% of traders entering the market are losing capital.

A Disturbing Trend

The ease of doing business in the Indian market, coupled with extremely low brokerages, has fueled the speculative frenzy surrounding derivatives trading. Many young investors view it as a quick ticket to wealth, disregarding the need for experience, proper training, and strategies. There seems to be a misconception that anyone can enter the market, borrow capital, and make substantial profits. However, this reckless approach to trading puts not only individuals at risk of losing their hard-earned money but also has the potential to destroy the fabric of hard work and perseverance in our society.

A Global Perspective

Comparing India’s derivatives turnover ratio to other markets reveals the extent of the phenomenon. Even in the highly speculative US market, the ratio is a mere nine times, while markets in Hong Kong, Brazil, South Korea, Israel, and Germany stand at five times, twelve to seventeen times, and thirty-six times, respectively. Prior to 2019, India was on par with Germany in terms of F&O turnover to cash turnover. However, the current figures indicate a drastic increase, raising concerns and necessitating a closer examination of the situation.

The derivatives trading mania not only presents risks for individual traders but also has broader implications for investors and the stability of the Indian market. While the frenzy may not impact India’s overall growth or the perception of foreign investors, the disproportionate rise in derivatives trading compared to investments is an area of significant concern. A growing number of dormant Demat accounts, as reported by many stock brokerage houses, further supports this observation. Many individuals have opened trading and Demat accounts without actively participating in the cash market. This skewed ratio of derivatives to cash trading should prompt us to reflect on the underlying issues at play and their potential consequences.

Addressing the Concerns

It is essential for regulators, market participants, and investors to address the concerns associated with the derivatives trading mania. SEBI’s role in monitoring and overseeing market activities becomes crucial in ensuring fair and transparent trading practices. Measures should be taken to educate and raise awareness among traders and potential investors about the risks involved in derivatives trading. Emphasis should be placed on understanding market dynamics, developing sound investment strategies, and employing risk management techniques.

To restore balance and curb the speculative frenzy, the Indian market may require a sustained bear market or a prolonged sideways market movement. Such conditions would test the mettle of thrill-seeking traders, highlighting the need for well-thought-out strategies and proper risk assessment. Only through experiences like these can we hope to recalibrate the expectations of traders and investors alike.

If you have any questions, please write to support@weekendinvesting.com